Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Early Ming armour.
China History Forum, Chinese History Forum > Chinese History Topics > Ancient Chinese Arsenal
Conan the destroyer
I'm looking for information on Ming armour 1368-1500. I can find a very few relevant illustrations from this period, and most of them depict mythical figures or heavenly beings. Many of these show soldiers in two layers of armour--usually a lamellar or brigandine vest with mail worn underneath. But I've seen others depicting soldiers in mail over a thick padded jacket, with metal scales stitched to the sleeves.

Are their any sources I can consult/research to find out more?

Much appreciated.
Conan the destroyer
Anybody? huh.gif
Yun
A Ming helmet that was recently auctioned on eBay. Comments?









http://cgi.ebay.fr/Stunning-Chinese-Ming-D...2QQcmdZViewItem
Conan the destroyer
Hmmm, it has the "wings" at the sides which are a common feature on Chinese helmets, as well as the spike at the top. But I've never seen a historical example constructed like this.
Yun


I guess this famous tomb guardian statue above isn't within your period? I think it's from Wanli's tomb in Beijing.

This one is from the Confucius family cemetery at Qufu: http://static.flickr.com/25/40632591_9745202de8.jpg?v=0

Some good ones in the early Ming tombs at Nanjing (including Zhu Yuanzhang's, Xu Da's, and Chang Yuchun's):
http://www.jllib.org.cn/ffy/mingsdsk (unfortunately the pictures are small)


(European tourists at Zhu Yuanzhang's tomb in the 19th century?)
Conan the destroyer
I'm familiar with the Ming tomb guardians. I'm hoping to find some other depictions.
Conan the destroyer
Yun, I've found an image of Ming cavalry dating from the early years of the dynasty. The horses are depicted in full lamellar armour, the riders are also armoured and wielding long hafted swords. I was always under the impression that Ming horses were unarmoured, any comments on this?

Much appreciated.
Yun
QUOTE
Yun, I've found an image of Ming cavalry dating from the early years of the dynasty. The horses are depicted in full lamellar armour, the riders are also armoured and wielding long hafted swords. I was always under the impression that Ming horses were unarmoured, any comments on this?

Much appreciated.


Any way you could put the picture up here?
Conan the destroyer
It's posted by Ihsan at the bottom of this thread. http://steppes.proboards23.com/index.cgi?b...read=1100795615

I doubt this sketch is Persian as the Osprey book implies. It looks like a Ming illustration that somehow made it's way to Iran.
Yun


The horse armour is almost identical to that illustrated in the Wujing Zongyao, and also to the painting where your avatar comes from - a Song depiction of the Tang general Guo Ziyi receiving the allegiance of Uyghur troops. So it is clearly a Song style of horse armour. It's also seen in the Cai Wenji scroll, which supposedly models its cavalry armour on contemporary Song and Jurchen armies. That distinctive crest on the horse's head is always there.

I don't know if this style survived into the Ming - closer dating of that picture would help.
Conan the destroyer
I'm not sure on the date this picture was drawn. But it's in Ming style artistry, and appears in a Persian album dating to the early 15th century.
Yun
Song horse armour in the Cai Wenji scroll:

TMPikachu
"Many of these show soldiers in two layers of armour--usually a lamellar or brigandine vest with mail worn underneath. But I've seen others depicting soldiers in mail over a thick padded jacket, with metal scales stitched to the sleeves."

Conan, I've never seen pictures of Chinese in mail armor before, could you post them please? The padded armor+mail+scales is also something I don't think I've ever seen before.

I've only seen the usual lamellar/brigandine stuff.
I could host the images for you if you email them.
Conan the destroyer
QUOTE(TMPikachu @ Jan 18 2006, 06:27 PM) [snapback]4784575[/snapback]
"Many of these show soldiers in two layers of armour--usually a lamellar or brigandine vest with mail worn underneath. But I've seen others depicting soldiers in mail over a thick padded jacket, with metal scales stitched to the sleeves."

Conan, I've never seen pictures of Chinese in mail armor before, could you post them please? The padded armor+mail+scales is also something I don't think I've ever seen before.

I've only seen the usual lamellar/brigandine stuff.
I could host the images for you if you email them.


Sure, check Thomas Chen's website for images of imperial guards in mail. This isn't lamellar--look at Ming illustrations of soldiers in lamellar and you will see why. Besides, a book I have on Chinese costumes describes these guys as wearing mail.
http://chineseswords.freewebspace.com/photo5.html

I have an image of Ming guardians in two layers of armour (lamellar underneath, and what looks like a Brigandine vest over the top), which I'll send you when I have time...
Friend From Far
QUOTE
IPB Image

The horse armour is almost identical to that illustrated in the Wujing Zongyao, and also to the painting where your avatar comes from - a Song depiction of the Tang general Guo Ziyi receiving the allegiance of Uyghur troops. So it is clearly a Song style of horse armour. It's also seen in the Cai Wenji scroll, which supposedly models its cavalry armour on contemporary Song and Jurchen armies. That distinctive crest on the horse's head is always there.

I don't know if this style survived into the Ming - closer dating of that picture would help.


What's does the inscription on the left upper corner say? g.gif Can someone read that Arab inscription?
TMPikachu
thankyou very much. You're right, I never realised it. I just thought "why are they wearing scale and not lamellar like the other soldiers?"

Do you know how their arm guards attached and what they were? Is it similiar to what Japanese arm guards were like? I think on Thomas Chen's armor website I saw one attached to brigandine, I imagine it's the same way.
Conan the destroyer
TMPikachu, this description of Chinese soldiers from 1415 might interest you...

Filling the courtyard, were long ranks of our Chinese soldiers in shining helmets and coats of mail, with spears, swords, bows and arrows, looking martial and lusty.

Source: The Rise of Islam and the Bengal Frontier, 1204-1760

This is a record from a Chinese ambassador in India.
Thomas Chen
Late 1400s Sino-Tibetan Ming Dynasty helmet, in the collection of the Royal Armouries, UK


______________________________


Early 1400s jian guards:
http://chineseswords2.freewebspace.com/custom.html

______________________________


Late Ming 1590s onwards --- helmet, saber and spearhead:

http://forums.swordforum.com/showthread.ph...&threadid=51372

__________________________________


Guess most of you would have seen these: 2 pics of Imperial Guards guarding the Ming Emperor Jiajing (1522-1567, who is not shown here) :

http://thomaschen.freewebspace.com/photo6.html
Conan the destroyer
Thomas,

Are those Ming swords of all metal construction, or are my eyes fooling me?
Thomas Chen
QUOTE(Conan the destroyer @ Jan 20 2006, 04:30 PM) [snapback]4785018[/snapback]
Thomas,

Are those Ming swords of all metal construction, or are my eyes fooling me?


Which Ming sword are you referring to, the 3 jians or the Ming saber?? The fittings such as the guard of the Ming saber are definitely iron...
Conan the destroyer
Sorry--I should have been more clear. I'm referring to the Jians.
TMPikachu
QUOTE(Conan the destroyer @ Jan 19 2006, 06:35 PM) [snapback]4784879[/snapback]
TMPikachu, this description of Chinese soldiers from 1415 might interest you...

Filling the courtyard, were long ranks of our Chinese soldiers in shining helmets and coats of mail, with spears, swords, bows and arrows, looking martial and lusty.


this ambassador is very proud of his country biggrin.gif

So these were Chinese soldiers in India?

also, I remember seeing posted here a few months ago, it was a suit of armor. Had a helmet with the 'wings' at the sides and I think the body armor was chain-and-lamellar. Like small metal squares linked by mail. Do any of you remember where that image came from, or have it saved?
Conan the destroyer
QUOTE(TMPikachu @ Jan 20 2006, 05:06 PM) [snapback]4785027[/snapback]
So these were Chinese soldiers in India?


Yes.

QUOTE(TMPikachu @ Jan 20 2006, 05:06 PM) [snapback]4785027[/snapback]
this ambassador is very proud of his country biggrin.gif

So these were Chinese soldiers in India?

also, I remember seeing posted here a few months ago, it was a suit of armor. Had a helmet with the 'wings' at the sides and I think the body armor was chain-and-lamellar. Like small metal squares linked by mail. Do any of you remember where that image came from, or have it saved?


It was posted by Wujiang on the Ancient Chinese Arsenal forum, you should be able to find it quickly with a search.
Thomas Chen
Yes, some form of metal, probably bronze for the first two pieces from the left.... The third piece from the left appear to be iron inlaid with silver...
Conan the destroyer
Hey everyone, check out these illustrations of Ming soldiers in double armour. Probably mail+brigandine...
http://www.nsu.ru/aw/bookloader?id=134&part=resource
http://www.nsu.ru/aw/bookloader?id=135&part=resource
Conan the destroyer
Could somebody shed light on the "Willow Leaf armour" of the Ming period?
TMPikachu
QUOTE(Conan the destroyer @ Feb 25 2006, 05:37 AM) [snapback]4791823[/snapback]
Could somebody shed light on the "Willow Leaf armour" of the Ming period?


My guess, based on what I've read in books, willow leaf refers to a lamellar armor, the metal scales giving it that name. How it's different from other lamellars I don't know, but in general lamellar armor uses smaller and more scales with the advancement of time.
Conan the destroyer
Ok, I've just seen an image of what appears to be a Ming dynasty statue depicting a warrior dressed in what appears to be a suit of chain-and-plate armour.
TMPikachu
Have you taken pictures, or could you tell me where it could be found?
Conan the destroyer
QUOTE(TMPikachu @ May 5 2006, 10:42 PM) [snapback]4808841[/snapback]
Have you taken pictures, or could you tell me where it could be found?


i saw it on swordforum, i'll look for it tomorrow, it's late here in the uk.
Boleslaw I
QUOTE(Yun @ Jan 18 2006, 06:50 AM) *


The horse armour is almost identical to that illustrated in the Wujing Zongyao, and also to the painting where your avatar comes from - a Song depiction of the Tang general Guo Ziyi receiving the allegiance of Uyghur troops. So it is clearly a Song style of horse armour. It's also seen in the Cai Wenji scroll, which supposedly models its cavalry armour on contemporary Song and Jurchen armies. That distinctive crest on the horse's head is always there.

I don't know if this style survived into the Ming - closer dating of that picture would help.


This is a Persian painting which depicted a league of almost identical Chinese cavalry. Those were Northern enemy of Timurid emperor: Tamerlane, you can find it in Osprey: The Era Of Timurid. Please do acknowledge the source as well.
青島Aoshima
QUOTE(Conan the destroyer @ Jan 16 2006, 09:53 AM) *
I'm looking for information on Ming armour 1368-1500. I can find a very few relevant illustrations from this period, and most of them depict mythical figures or heavenly beings. Many of these show soldiers in two layers of armour--usually a lamellar or brigandine vest with mail worn underneath. But I've seen others depicting soldiers in mail over a thick padded jacket, with metal scales stitched to the sleeves.

Are their any sources I can consult/research to find out more?

Much appreciated.

i have a dodgy picture of a badly made replica lol...if your interested
Taran ap Dafydd
I'm interested, Aoshima...




QUOTE (Conan the destroyer @ Jan 19 2006, 07:35 PM) *
TMPikachu, this description of Chinese soldiers from 1415 might interest you...

Filling the courtyard, were long ranks of our Chinese soldiers in shining helmets and coats of mail, with spears, swords, bows and arrows, looking martial and lusty.

Source: The Rise of Islam and the Bengal Frontier, 1204-1760

This is a record from a Chinese ambassador in India.


Just wanted to remind folks that scale armours of all kinds, including lamellars, are often referred to as a form of mail. Just because descriptions include the word "mail" doesn't mean it's chain.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.